Joseph Yam faults
Marred By Lehman ‘Blip’
By Theresa Tang and Kelvin Wong
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601080&sid=aOfGLXMFlMXE&refer=asia
May 20 (Bloomberg) -- Joseph Yam, who’s retiring as Hong Kong’s central banker, steered the city through the Asian financial crisis, a bank run and an epidemic -- only to get burned by the collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.
Yam, 60, will exit on Oct. 1 as the chief executive officer of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, the government said yesterday. His replacement hasn’t been named.
During a 16-year stint that made him Asia’s longest-serving central banker, Yam fended off an attack by speculators on Hong Kong’s currency peg and developed the city’s monetary system, which he steered through the British handover to China in 1997. The blot on his legacy may be failing as a regulator to prevent the sale to vulnerable investors, including the elderly and the mentally ill, of complex securities linked to Lehman.
“It’s a small blip on a remarkably long and tremendous service,” said Charles Goodhart, a former Bank of England policy maker who has known Yam since 1983 when Goodhart was an adviser on establishing Hong Kong’s dollar peg. “The Hong Kong financial system has remained stable while many around it have not. He’s been through some difficult patches and has managed them with great strength and purpose.”
Norman Chan, a former Yam deputy who is now an aide to Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang, is a possible replacement, the Hong Kong Standard reported May 15. Calls last night to Chan’s office and mobile telephone went unanswered. Yam declined an interview request last week, and Thomas Chan, the HKMA spokesman, couldn’t be contacted last night.
‘Most Effective’
“They’re going to miss him; he’s not going to be easy to replace,” former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan said in an interview yesterday. “He was one of the most effective central bankers in the world for a long period of time.”
Yam leaves unresolved for his successor the “inherent contradiction” of a role that spans both financial regulation and fund management, said Billy Mak, a finance professor at Baptist University in Hong Kong. The HKMA manages the $193 billion pool of assets that backs the Hong Kong currency’s fixed exchange rate. Yam helped put together the U.S. dollar-linked system in 1983.
He joined the civil service in 1971 as a statistician after graduating from the University of Hong Kong and became an economist in 1976. His departure follows eight months of almost daily protests by investors after the failure of Lehman threatened the savings of thousands who bought securities called minibonds.
Security Buyers
Hong Kong banks sold the notes to older, poorly educated and mentally ill people, according to an HKMA report that legislators released last month. Individuals bought a total of HK$13.9 billion ($1.8 billion), according to the Securities and Futures Commission.
Yip Hau-wah, a 56-year-old hospital worker, said she lost half her HK$56,000 savings in minibonds that she purchased after getting cold-called from sales staff at a BOC Hong Kong Holdings Ltd. branch.
If Yam “has any intention to help us, he would’ve pressured the bank to refund us already,” she said during a May 15 protest.
Legislators including Chim Pui-chung, who represents the financial-services industry, have urged Yam to formally apologize to investors.
“This is a stain for Yambo,” he said. The nickname derives from the movie about the vengeful Vietnam veteran, “Rambo,” and was applied to Yam after his successful defense of the currency peg during the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis.
Compensation Criticism
Yam’s compensation has also attracted criticism. In 2008, he received HK$11.9 million ($1.5 million), compared with Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke’s $191,300 and Bank of England Governor Mervyn King’s 283,564 pounds ($400,000) in 2007. Central Banking Publications described him last year as the highest-paid central banker in the world.
The criticisms contrast with his achievements.
“Under his guard, Hong Kong has emerged in good shape from the past few banking and financial crises; that includes the Asian financial crisis, the Internet bubble and the current global credit crunch,” Mak said.
Yam directed $15 billion of stock purchases to successfully defend Hong Kong’s dollar 11 years ago, standing up to Greenspan in the process. Greenspan slammed the move, telling members of the U.S. House of Representatives Banking Committee that the step “won’t succeed” and would erode “some of the extraordinary credibility” of the HKMA.
‘Where it Hurts’
Yam countered by saying his stock purchases would hit speculators “where it hurts” by causing losses on short positions on the city’s shares and currency. A short position profits from declines in a security.
“I hated having to intervene in the markets,” Yam told Bloomberg in an interview last September. “I’m a believer in free markets.”
In the interview yesterday, Greenspan said his concern at the time was that “it’s very risky for a central bank to intervene in your domestic market, or you may end up with a very large share of the outstanding securities.”
In retrospect, Greenspan said, Yam’s timing “was exquisite. He picked the bottom of the market. Global stock prices rose very significantly over the next two or three years. I told him he was right, and I shouldn’t have been concerned.”
During his tenure, Yam also navigated Hong Kong’s financial system through the economic slump caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, in 2003, which killed almost 300 people in the city as tourists stayed away, leading to empty hotels and restaurants. He also offered assurances and extended deposit insurance to end a run last year on the Bank of East Asia Ltd.
Hong Kong’s lawmakers voted May 6 against a motion calling for Yam to step down.
“The Hong Kong Monetary Authority has done a good job in regulating banks,” David Li, Bank of East Asia’s chairman and the banking-sector representative in the city legislature, said during the debate. “Hong Kong banks have continued to function well in the current financial crisis, and this isn’t based on luck.”
By Theresa Tang and Kelvin Wong
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601080&sid=aOfGLXMFlMXE&refer=asia
May 20 (Bloomberg) -- Joseph Yam, who’s retiring as Hong Kong’s central banker, steered the city through the Asian financial crisis, a bank run and an epidemic -- only to get burned by the collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.
Yam, 60, will exit on Oct. 1 as the chief executive officer of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, the government said yesterday. His replacement hasn’t been named.
During a 16-year stint that made him Asia’s longest-serving central banker, Yam fended off an attack by speculators on Hong Kong’s currency peg and developed the city’s monetary system, which he steered through the British handover to China in 1997. The blot on his legacy may be failing as a regulator to prevent the sale to vulnerable investors, including the elderly and the mentally ill, of complex securities linked to Lehman.
“It’s a small blip on a remarkably long and tremendous service,” said Charles Goodhart, a former Bank of England policy maker who has known Yam since 1983 when Goodhart was an adviser on establishing Hong Kong’s dollar peg. “The Hong Kong financial system has remained stable while many around it have not. He’s been through some difficult patches and has managed them with great strength and purpose.”
Norman Chan, a former Yam deputy who is now an aide to Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang, is a possible replacement, the Hong Kong Standard reported May 15. Calls last night to Chan’s office and mobile telephone went unanswered. Yam declined an interview request last week, and Thomas Chan, the HKMA spokesman, couldn’t be contacted last night.
‘Most Effective’
“They’re going to miss him; he’s not going to be easy to replace,” former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan said in an interview yesterday. “He was one of the most effective central bankers in the world for a long period of time.”
Yam leaves unresolved for his successor the “inherent contradiction” of a role that spans both financial regulation and fund management, said Billy Mak, a finance professor at Baptist University in Hong Kong. The HKMA manages the $193 billion pool of assets that backs the Hong Kong currency’s fixed exchange rate. Yam helped put together the U.S. dollar-linked system in 1983.
He joined the civil service in 1971 as a statistician after graduating from the University of Hong Kong and became an economist in 1976. His departure follows eight months of almost daily protests by investors after the failure of Lehman threatened the savings of thousands who bought securities called minibonds.
Security Buyers
Hong Kong banks sold the notes to older, poorly educated and mentally ill people, according to an HKMA report that legislators released last month. Individuals bought a total of HK$13.9 billion ($1.8 billion), according to the Securities and Futures Commission.
Yip Hau-wah, a 56-year-old hospital worker, said she lost half her HK$56,000 savings in minibonds that she purchased after getting cold-called from sales staff at a BOC Hong Kong Holdings Ltd. branch.
If Yam “has any intention to help us, he would’ve pressured the bank to refund us already,” she said during a May 15 protest.
Legislators including Chim Pui-chung, who represents the financial-services industry, have urged Yam to formally apologize to investors.
“This is a stain for Yambo,” he said. The nickname derives from the movie about the vengeful Vietnam veteran, “Rambo,” and was applied to Yam after his successful defense of the currency peg during the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis.
Compensation Criticism
Yam’s compensation has also attracted criticism. In 2008, he received HK$11.9 million ($1.5 million), compared with Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke’s $191,300 and Bank of England Governor Mervyn King’s 283,564 pounds ($400,000) in 2007. Central Banking Publications described him last year as the highest-paid central banker in the world.
The criticisms contrast with his achievements.
“Under his guard, Hong Kong has emerged in good shape from the past few banking and financial crises; that includes the Asian financial crisis, the Internet bubble and the current global credit crunch,” Mak said.
Yam directed $15 billion of stock purchases to successfully defend Hong Kong’s dollar 11 years ago, standing up to Greenspan in the process. Greenspan slammed the move, telling members of the U.S. House of Representatives Banking Committee that the step “won’t succeed” and would erode “some of the extraordinary credibility” of the HKMA.
‘Where it Hurts’
Yam countered by saying his stock purchases would hit speculators “where it hurts” by causing losses on short positions on the city’s shares and currency. A short position profits from declines in a security.
“I hated having to intervene in the markets,” Yam told Bloomberg in an interview last September. “I’m a believer in free markets.”
In the interview yesterday, Greenspan said his concern at the time was that “it’s very risky for a central bank to intervene in your domestic market, or you may end up with a very large share of the outstanding securities.”
In retrospect, Greenspan said, Yam’s timing “was exquisite. He picked the bottom of the market. Global stock prices rose very significantly over the next two or three years. I told him he was right, and I shouldn’t have been concerned.”
During his tenure, Yam also navigated Hong Kong’s financial system through the economic slump caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, in 2003, which killed almost 300 people in the city as tourists stayed away, leading to empty hotels and restaurants. He also offered assurances and extended deposit insurance to end a run last year on the Bank of East Asia Ltd.
Hong Kong’s lawmakers voted May 6 against a motion calling for Yam to step down.
“The Hong Kong Monetary Authority has done a good job in regulating banks,” David Li, Bank of East Asia’s chairman and the banking-sector representative in the city legislature, said during the debate. “Hong Kong banks have continued to function well in the current financial crisis, and this isn’t based on luck.”
1 則留言:
I had promised my friends and brother-in-law that I would finished him off even Joseph Yam believed that he is the scapegoat of Donald Tsang failed policy to build HK as a Asia financial center , but his inability to control those 19 local banks that mis-sold Minibonds and other derivative products showed he is also guilt himself in neglecting HK common people. After Legistrator Chim Pui-chung called him a US spy that only help US investment bankers to steal HK people money in Cable TV, the Minibonds saga unfolded immediately. I believed in Chim and at once sent complaint letters to Legco listing HKMA inaction during crisis. Joseph Yam did informed Legco in special session that he did warned about HK banks in the credit crunch crisis in 2007 but his associates sold him out in discussion.com.hk that his warnings applied only to investment bankers that only issued Minibonds and related products but only public banking sold these products. So I started writing complaint leters to about his warning did not applied to public banks in Legco, OMD, HK financial services, CEO of HK, SFC. His neglect of HK banks mis-selling were exposed in Legco sessions and finally James To pointed out that he never did not do his duties as head of HKMA to warn Minibonds victims in order to protect the banks
發佈留言
訂閱 發佈留言 [Atom]
<< 首頁